Why does America feel worse than other countries? Crime.

I’ve been wanting to write this post for a while, actually. What triggered it was seeing this tweet:

Extreme tolerance of public disorder, and downplaying the importance of crime, is a hallmark of modern progressive American culture. There are plenty of Democrats who care about crime — Joe Biden recently tried to increase the number of police in America by a substantial amount — but there is constant pressure from the left against such measures. On social media, calls for greater public order are instantly met with accusations of racism and classism:

(And this was far from the most radical post on the topic.)

Nor is this attitude confined to anonymous radicals on social media. When Biden announced his Safer America Plan, the ACLU warned that putting more cops on the streets and punishing drug dealers would exacerbate racial disparities:

[I]n this moment of fear and concern, the president must not repeat yesterday’s mistakes today. He calls for hiring 100,000 additional state and local police officers – the same increase in officers as the 1994 crime bill. This failed strategy did not make America safer, instead it resulted in massive over-policing and rampant rights violations in our communities…And while it is important that the president’s plan commits to fixing the racist sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine, it regrettably also perpetuates the war on drugs by calling for harsh new penalties for fentanyl offenses.

“While we are pleased with the president’s commitment to investing in communities, we strongly urge him not to repeat the grave errors of the 1990s — policies that exacerbated racial disparities, contributed to widespread police abuses, and created our current crisis of mass incarceration.

The ACLU is very wrong about policing and crime — there’s very solid evidence that having more cops around reduces the amount of crime, both by deterring criminals and by getting them off the streets.

In fact, the idea that tough-on-crime policies are racist is a pillar of progressive thought. It’s the thesis of Michelle Alexander’s influential 2012 book The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness, which argues that mass incarceration is a form of racial segregation. Ta-Nehisi Coates, perhaps the most important progressive thinker of the 2010s, relentlessly attacked the “carceral state”.

A major progressive policy initiative, meanwhile, has been the election or appointment of district attorneys