Europe Fires a Speech Warning
Deep Dives
Explore related topics with these Wikipedia articles, rewritten for enjoyable reading:
-
Digital Services Act
13 min read
The article centers on this EU law and its first major enforcement action against X. Understanding the DSA's full scope, requirements, and enforcement mechanisms provides essential context for the fine and broader regulatory debate.
-
Margrethe Vestager
17 min read
The article profiles her as a key figure in EU tech regulation, mentions she inspired a TV character, and notes Trump branded her the 'tax lady.' Her background and antitrust career illuminate the EU's regulatory philosophy.
-
Network Enforcement Act
13 min read
The article references Germany's content moderation laws as a 'template' for global regulation and mentions playwright C.J. Hopkins facing charges. Germany's NetzDG was the pioneering national law that influenced the DSA's approach to platform liability.
From the New York Times:
The European Union on Friday fined X, the social media company owned by Elon Musk, $140 million for violating one of the bloc’s major laws targeting the technology industry… X is the first company to be fined under the European Union’s Digital Services Act, a sweeping law intended to force large internet companies to protect their platforms against manipulation and illicit content… In addition to Mr. Musk’s ties to the Trump administration… Mr. Musk has also become involved in European politics, backing far-right groups like the Alternative for Germany party.
The Digital Services Act, the European Commission’s content control law developed across multiple stages dating to the mid-2010s, has finally become fully operational, in Star Wars parlance. Officials announced a long-threatened €120 million (about $140 million) fine of Elon Musk’s X platform, with the major offenses being the use of a “deceptive” check mark program and failure to “provide researchers with access to the platform’s public data.”
The fine comes at a strange time. A few weeks ago, the EC began a public campaign of walking back its biggest censorship initiatives, thanks to a growing belief that its stifling regulatory environment was costing Old-World companies a chance to compete for investment in AI technology. Last summer, Europe’s former Vice President Margrethe Vestager — a tough-talking Danish pol who inspires heartburn in CEOs and is said to be the inspiration for the character of Birgitte Nyborg in the political drama Borgen — took the lead not only in Digital Markets Act cases against Apple and Meta, but in trolling CEOs like Musk over alleged DSA violations. Musk responded by accusing the EU of offering to drop their DSA case if they “censored speech without telling anyone.”
A year later, Vestager — branded the “tax lady” who “really hates the U.S.” by Donald Trump — is out, and President Ursula Von der Leyen is reportedly trying to push Europe in a less punitive direction, under the auspices of a plan loosely called digital simplification. “Regulation cannot be the best export product of the E.U.,” said Finnish parliamentarian Aura Salla.
Still, the fine of Musk and X isn’t surprising, given anxiety on the continent about the rise of Trump and nationalist movements in key countries like Germany and the U.K. Although EC politicians seem to be
...This excerpt is provided for preview purposes. Full article content is available on the original publication.